The Montana Weekly Work Comp Brief – #55 – November 16, 2026

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Montana Workers’ Compensation Court

Rutledge v. Technology Insurance Co., Inc., 2026 MTWCC 11

Decision Date: November 13, 2026

Attorneys:

Megan Miller for Rutledge;

Joe C. Maynard for Technology Insurance Co.

Factual Summary and Decision

Rutledge sustained a concussion and neck strain in a January 2024 industrial accident while employed by Hoven Equipment. His employer terminated his employment in April 2025 because of his medical condition and need for additional leave. Although Rutledge had not reached maximum medical improvement (MMI), his treating provider subsequently released him to modified duty. Hoven offered him a newly created position consistent with his medical restrictions, at his previous wage and with reinstated benefits. Rutledge declined, arguing that his prior termination eliminated any obligation to return to work.

The Court granted the insurer’s motion for summary judgment, holding that § 39-71-701(4), MCA, permits termination of temporary total disability (TTD) benefits when a worker refuses suitable modified employment offered by the time-of-injury employer, even after the employer previously terminated the employment relationship.

The Court further determined that the employer’s written job description sufficiently demonstrated compliance with the medical restrictions, that formal physician approval of a job analysis was unnecessary under these circumstances, and that the insurer satisfied the applicable 14-day notice requirement. The Court rejected Rutledge’s reliance on § 39-71-609(2), MCA, which governs conversion of TTD to PPD benefits, and denied his requests for attorney fees and a penalty.

Key Takeaway

An employer’s prior termination of an injured worker does not prevent the insurer from terminating pre-MMI TTD benefits when that employer subsequently offers suitable modified employment at an equivalent wage and the worker refuses. A written job description consistent with specific medical restrictions may suffice without formal physician approval of a job analysis. However, challenges to the suitability of the offered employment must be supported by substantive evidence rather than speculation.

Practical Significance: This decision strengthens insurers’ ability to terminate TTD benefits following refusal of modified employment and emphasizes the importance of developing medical and vocational evidence demonstrating why an offered position is unsuitable.

 SUBMITTED MATTERS
      Motions & Miscellaneous Matters
Case Pleading Date Submitted
Guitron v. UEF UEF’s Motion for Summary Judgment 5/15/26

 

Guitron v. UEF Villegas Del Villar’s Motion for Summary Judgment 5/20/26

 

Fievet v. FedEx Freight, Inc.

 

Respondent’s Motion for Summary Judgment 9/10/26
Boyer v. Montana State Fund

 

Petitioner’s Motion for Partial Summary Judgment 9/11/26
Mathiason v. Montana State Fund Petitioner’s Motion in Limine 9/25/26
Fievet v. FedEx Freight, Inc.

 

Petitioner’s Cross Motion for Summary Judgment 10/2/26
Burns v. Montana State Fund Petitioner’s Motion for Sanctions for Spoilation of Evidence

 

10/9/26
Glover v. Montana State Fund

 

Respondent’s Motion for Summary Judgment 10/27/26
SFR Performance, LLC v. ICCU ICCU’s Untimely Motion to Joint Necessary Third Party, and Clarify ICCU’s Position 10/30/26
     
Rader v. UEF Petitioner’s Motion to Compel Sworn Interrogatory Answers 11/8/26
     Upcoming Trials, Hearings & Conferences

 None Currently Scheduled.

Montana Workers’ Compensation Stipulations Summary (week ending November 13, 2026)
PLAN 1         
Case Name DOI Body Part(s) Settlement Type Settlement Amount Petitioner Attorney Respondent Attorney
Linda Overman v. Providence Health * Services / St. Patrick Hospital & Health Sciences Ctr. Multiple (6) Multiple; Full and Final – Medicals Closed $24,850.00 Bradford, R. Spencer

Bulman Jones & Cook PLLC

Smith, Charlie

Crowley Fleck PLLP

PLAN 2
Case Name DOI Body Part(s) Settlement Type Settlement Amount Petitioner Attorney Respondent Attorney
Jami Ellis v. Praetorian Ins. Co. 3/11/26 Shoulder; Full and Final – Medicals Closed $90,000.00 May, Stockton

Fair Claim Lawyers

Maynard, Joe

Crowley Fleck PLLP

Logan Katterman v. Great West Casualty Co. 12/18/25 Low back; Right shoulder; Full and Final – Medicals Closed $85,000.00 Murphy, Matthew

Murphy Law Firm

Maynard, Joe

Crowley Fleck PLLP

Jonathan Nyberg v. Old Republic Ins. Co. 12/4/23 Right hand; Full and Final – Medicals Closed $40,000.00 Lighthall, David

Carey Law Firm, P.C.

Smith, Charlie

Crowley Fleck PLLP

ESD Settlements Approved through November 6, 2026
PLAN 1
Claimant Name DOI Body Part Settlement Type Settlement Amount Attorney Name
Guscott, Amber 1/8/25 Knee; Petition for Settlement – Medicals Closed $32,500.00 Murphy, Tommy
Perrin, Megan 9/14/26 Multiple body parts; Disputed Initial Compensability $2,000.00 None
PLAN 2
Claimant Name DOI Body Part Settlement Type Settlement Amount Attorney Name
Canen, Timothy 3/4/25 Ankle; Best Interests $10,000.00 None
Liles, Britney 6/21/24 Low back; Best Interests $15,000.00 Moore, Kraig
Llamas, Silvia 10/17/24 Multiple body parts; Best Interests $100,000.00 Everett, J. Ben
Lyles, Preston 12/28/23 Soft tissue; Best Interests $95,000.00 Miller, Andrew
PLAN 3
Claimant Name DOI Body Part Settlement Type Settlement Amount Attorney Name
Butts, Jared 5/29/26 Internal organs Disputed Initial Compensability $3,350.00 None
Dibble, Joyce 9/1/26 Knee; Disputed Initial Compensability $400.00 None
Forsman, Samantha 9/13/26 Pelvis Disputed Initial Compensability $1,400.00 None
Fusci, James 8/28/23 Upper back; Best Interests $15,000.00 None
Gallagher, Arvan 11/14/25 Soft tissue; Disputed Initial Compensability $40,000.00 Dalpiaz, Leslae
Huff, Eric 9/28/26 Facial bones; Disputed Initial Compensability $3,500.00 None
Jordan, Trey 4/22/24 Foot; Best Interests $74,108.81 Murphy, Matthew
Kelly, Tammy 1/23/26 Upper back; Best Interests $3,100.00 None
Martin, Kelly 9/17/26 Skull; Disputed Initial Compensability $975.00 None
McGreevey, John 10/3/22 Multiple upper extremities; Best Interests $50,000.00 Murphy, Matthew
Slusher, Kelly 8/16/25 Ankle; Best Interests $90,000.00 Dalpiaz, Miranda
Stewart, Elizabeth 2/5/25 Multiple lower extremities; Disputed Initial Compensability $55,000.00 Dalpiaz, Leslae
Vierzba, Bridget 4/28/25 Low back; Best Interests $24,210.66 None
Key Insights for Montana Work Comp Professionals
  1. WCC Expands Insurers’ Ability to Terminate TTD Following Refusal of Modified Employment

In Rutledge v. Technology Insurance Co., 2026 MTWCC 11, the Court held that an employer’s prior termination of an injured worker does not prevent a subsequent offer of suitable modified employment from supporting termination of TTD benefits under § 39-71-701(4), MCA. The Court also determined that formal physician approval of a job analysis was unnecessary under the circumstances. This decision underscores the importance of developing specific medical evidence challenging the suitability of modified-duty positions.

  1. WCC Stipulations Reflect Substantial Settlement Values

Four WCC stipulations totaled $239,850, with an average settlement of approximately $59,963. The largest were a $90,000 shoulder claim involving Jami Ellis and an $85,000 low-back/right-shoulder claim involving Logan Katterman. All four settlements closed medical benefits, illustrating the significant monetary consideration associated with full-and-final resolutions.

  1. ESD Settlements Demonstrate Wide Variations in Claim Valuation

The 19 ESD settlements reported totaled approximately $615,545, ranging from $400 to $100,000. The median settlement was $15,000, substantially below the average of approximately $32,397. This disparity illustrates how a relatively small number of higher-value settlements can skew averages and why settlement type, compensability, and medical exposure must be considered when evaluating claim values.

  1. Disputed Compensability Claims Can Produce Significant Settlements

Eight ESD settlements involved disputed initial compensability, totaling $106,625. Although five resolved for $3,500 or less, two settlements reached $40,000 and $55,000. These results demonstrate that disputed liability does not necessarily translate into minimal settlement exposure, particularly where the potential consequences of an adverse compensability determination are substantial.

  1. Pending WCC Motions Highlight Important Litigation Developments

The Court reported ten submitted motions, including multiple summary judgment motions, a motion to compel sworn interrogatory answers, and a motion for sanctions for alleged spoliation of evidence in Burns v. Montana State Fund. With no trials or hearings currently scheduled, the pending motions warrant attention because their resolution may clarify procedural obligations, evidentiary standards, and the disposition of contested claims.

Overall observation: The reporting period highlights two significant developments: the Rutledge decision provides insurers additional support for terminating TTD benefits following refusal of suitable modified employment, while the settlement data demonstrates substantial variation in claim valuation, including meaningful exposure in disputed compensability cases.

Work Comp Articles

  • The Montana Weekly…

    Montana Workers’ Compensation Court Rutledge v. Technology Insurance Co., Inc.,…

  • The Montana Weekly…

    Montana Workers’ Compensation Court      No decisions reported this…

  • The Montana Weekly…

    Montana Workers’ Compensation Court  No decisions this reporting period. SUBMITTED…

  • Free Case Review

    We’ll review your case for free. You won’t be limited by the clock. We will talk as long as necessary to understand your claim. We will give you a clear roadmap and help you understand the steps you can take to improve your position.

    Call Email